logo
Low-Carbon Transport & E-MobilityQuality

When Fuel Taxes Fade: Electrification and the Future of Road Financing Worldwide

Fuel taxes have funded roads for a century. Electric vehicles and more efficient engines are steadily eroding that base, and governments from Washington to Reykjavík are now redesigning how road users pay.

By AFRIHECOM Research Team24 October 20269 min read

Illustration: AFRIHECOM. A fading fuel pump beside an electric vehicle at a charger: the base for road revenue is shifting.

≈25%
of new cars sold worldwide in 2025 were electric, more than 20 million vehicles
IEA Global EV Outlook 2026
US$65bn+
net global shortfall in national fuel tax revenue projected by 2030
IEA Global EV Outlook 2025
2028
year the US Highway Trust Fund’s highway account is projected to run dry
Congressional Budget Office, June 2026

Key takeaways

  • About a quarter of new cars sold in 2025 were electric; adoption is accelerating in emerging markets too.[1]
  • Fuel-efficiency gains have already cut fuel tax collected by about 28% in Europe and 18% in the US, before EVs had a large effect.[6]
  • Low-income countries rely on fuel taxes for more than 9% of government revenue, about three times wealthier countries.[8]
  • The UK plans to charge EVs 3p per mile from April 2028; projected receipts would offset only part of falling fuel duty.[23][25]
  • Australia’s High Court struck down a state EV charge in 2023, showing that legal design matters as much as economics.[33]

For most of the twentieth century, a litre of fuel was a reasonable proxy for road use: the more you drove, the more fuel you bought, and the more tax you paid. That proxy is breaking down. Battery-electric vehicles pay no fuel tax at all, and conventional vehicles travel further on every litre. The result is a slow but structural erosion of one of the most important revenue sources for transport infrastructure. This article reviews the scale of that erosion and the responses now under way in different parts of the world.

The scale of the transition

More than 20 million electric cars were sold worldwide in 2025, about a quarter of all new cars,[1] and the global fleet of electric vehicles, excluding two- and three-wheelers, is nearly 80 million.[2] The pace varies widely: battery-electric cars made up 95.9% of new car sales in Norway, and electric cars about 55% in China and just under 10% in the United States.[3][4] Emerging markets are accelerating too, with record sales outside China and shares near 40% in Viet Nam.[4]

Figure 1

One in four new cars sold worldwide in 2025 was electric

Electric share of new car sales, 2025 (battery-electric and plug-in hybrid; Norway battery-electric only)

Norway
95.9%
China
≈55%
Viet Nam
≈40%
Germany
≈30%
Europe
28%
World
≈25%
Thailand
≈25%
Indonesia
15%
United States
<10%
Brazil
9%
India
≈4%
Sources: IEA, Global EV Outlook 2026; Norway: OFV registration data via The Local/AFP.[4][3] Norway’s 95.9% counts battery-electric cars only; the IEA’s figure of about 97% includes plug-in hybrids.
View the data as a table
MarketEV share of new car sales, 2025
Norway95.9%
China≈55%
Viet Nam≈40%
Germany≈30%
Europe28%
World≈25%
Thailand≈25%
Indonesia15%
United States<10%
Brazil9%
India≈4%

Two- and three-wheelers matter as much in many developing regions. About 11 million electric two- and three-wheelers were sold in 2025, and electric two-wheeler sales in Africa reached about 70,000, up from fewer than 1,000 in 2020.[5]

Erosion has two causes, not one

Electric vehicles are only part of the story. The ITF estimates that fuel-efficiency improvements have reduced fuel tax collected by about 28% in Europe and 18% in the United States. In Europe, fuel taxes fell from 10% to 4.4% of total tax revenue between 1995 and 2020, and US fuel tax revenue per vehicle-mile fell 34.4% between 1994 and 2018.[6] US analysts emphasise that electric vehicles did not cause the Highway Trust Fund’s problems; slower growth in driving, better fuel economy, rates frozen since 1993 and rising spending did.[7]

Globally, fuel taxes raised roughly US$900 billion in 2023. A 2026 analysis of 168 countries found that low-income countries rely on them for more than 9% of government revenue on average, about three times the share in wealthier countries.[8][9] The IEA projects that, under current policies, gasoline and diesel tax revenue at national level will fall from about US$560 billion in 2024 to about US$520 billion by 2030, with a net global shortfall of more than US$65 billion even after electricity taxes are counted. Europe accounts for about 55% of that shortfall.[10]

Figure 2

Poorer countries rely most on fuel taxes

Fuel tax revenue as a share of total government revenue (%)

Low- and lower-middle-income countriesrange
8–12%
Low-income countries, average
>9%average
Most countriestypical range
4–8%
Upper-middle and high-income countriesrange
2–4%
02468101214
Greater reliance →
Source: Noll, Schmidt and Egli, Nature Sustainability 2026, analysis of 168 countries.[8][9] The authors also find a modest negative correlation between exposure to fuel tax erosion and institutional quality.
View the data as a table
GroupFuel tax as % of government revenue
Low- and lower-middle-income8–12
Low-income average>9
Most countries4–8
Upper-middle and high-income2–4
The countries that depend most on fuel taxes are the least prepared to replace them, which makes early planning more valuable, not less.

United States: an unindexed tax meets its limit

The federal gasoline tax has been 18.4 US cents per gallon since 1993,[11] and has lost about 74% of its purchasing power since then.[12] The Congressional Budget Office projects that the transit account of the Highway Trust Fund will be exhausted in 2027 and the highway account in 2028, with a combined cumulative shortfall of about US$318 billion by 2036.[13] Congress has already transferred about US$275 billion from general revenue into the fund since 2007.[7]

Figure 3

The US Highway Trust Fund faces a growing gap

Cumulative shortfall, highway and transit accounts combined, US$ billion (CBO June 2026 baseline)

2028highway account exhausted
−25.8
2030
−96.2
2032
−166.6
2034
−240.0
2036
−317.9
Source: Congressional Budget Office, Baseline Projections: Highway Trust Fund Accounts, June 2026.[13] Values are the sum of CBO’s separate highway and transit account shortfalls (AFRIHECOM calculation), assuming spending consistent with CBO’s baseline. CBO projects the transit account to be exhausted in 2027 and the highway account in 2028.
View the data as a table
Fiscal yearCumulative shortfall (US$bn)
202825.8
203096.2
2032166.6
2034240.0
2036317.9

States have moved faster than Washington: 41 states now levy a special registration fee on electric vehicles, ranging from US$50 to US$270 a year.[14] A federal fee of US$250 a year for EVs (and US$100 for hybrids) was proposed in 2025 but not included in the final law.[15][16] The House BUILD America 250 Act (H.R. 8870), approved in committee in May 2026, would introduce a smaller fee of US$130 for EVs and US$35 for plug-in hybrids, rising to US$150 and US$50;[17] CBO estimates net revenue of about US$12.4 billion over 2026–2036 (about US$17 billion gross).[18] As of October 2026, surface transportation programmes were operating under a short-term extension and the fund’s solvency remained unresolved.[19]

United Kingdom: the first national pay-per-mile charge for EVs

UK fuel duty raised provisionally about £24.25 billion in 2025-26.[20] The main rate has not risen since 2011-12, and a temporary 5p cut made in 2022 is being reversed in stages between September 2026 and March 2027.[21] The Office for Budget Responsibility has projected that fuel duty will fall to zero in cash terms by 2050 on a net-zero pathway.[22]

In November 2025 the government announced an Electric Vehicle Excise Duty of 3p per mile for battery-electric cars and 1.5p for plug-in hybrids from April 2028, based on odometer readings and indexed to inflation from 2029-30; primary legislation is still to be introduced.[23] The rate is roughly half the average fuel duty paid per mile.[24] Projected receipts rise from about £1.1 billion in its first year to £1.9 billion by 2030-31, and the OBR estimates it will offset about a quarter of fuel duty losses by 2050.[23][25]

Figure 4

The UK’s planned pay-per-mile charge would replace only a fraction of fuel duty

UK fuel duty receipts and projected Electric Vehicle Excise Duty (eVED) revenue, £ billion

Fuel dutyeVED (projected)
Fuel duty, 2025-26provisional
£24.25bn
eVED, 2028-29first year
£1.10bn
eVED, 2029-30
£1.44bn
eVED, 2030-31
£1.87bn
Sources: HMRC 2026; HM Treasury and HMRC eVED policy paper, July 2026 (OBR-certified costings).[20][23] eVED is planned at 3p per mile for battery-electric cars and 1.5p for plug-in hybrids from April 2028. The OBR estimates it will offset about a quarter of the fuel duty lost by 2050.[25]
View the data as a table
Item£bn
Fuel duty receipts 2025-26 (provisional)24.25
eVED 2028-291.10
eVED 2029-301.435
eVED 2030-311.865

Europe: different starting points, different paths

Norway shows the fiscal cost of rapid electrification. The government estimates that car-related taxes in the 2025 budget were about NOK 50 billion lower than at 2007 tax levels, though not all of the reduction is due to EVs.[26] Norway is now phasing out its VAT exemption for electric cars, with full VAT from 2028,[27] and EVs pay between 50% and 70% of standard road tolls.[28] In contrast, the Netherlands, which once planned a nationwide kilometre charge by 2030, left it out of its 2026 coalition agreement, effectively shelving it.[29]

National analyses illustrate the stakes. French Treasury estimates suggest energy excise revenue of €43 billion in 2019 could fall by about €30 billion by 2050 at unchanged rates.[30] An OECD/ITF study for Slovenia projected a 56% fall in car fuel tax revenue by 2050 compared with 2017.[31]

Australia: when the constitution decides

Victoria introduced a charge of 2.5 Australian cents per km for electric and hydrogen vehicles (2.0 cents for plug-in hybrids) in 2021.[32] In October 2023 the High Court ruled 4–3 in Vanderstock v Victoria that it was a duty of excise, which only the Commonwealth may impose, and similar state charges were considered likely to be prohibited.[33] The ruling shows that legal and constitutional design can matter as much as economics. University of Sydney research has since modelled a national revenue-neutral charge of about 12 cents per km for most light vehicles, including a carbon component.[34]

Emerging and developing economies

For many developing countries the challenge is sharper. In 2019, fuel and oil taxes accounted for 10.2% of total taxation in middle-income countries, against 6.8% in high-income countries.[6] The 2026 global analysis identifies a group of countries with “double exposure”: high reliance on fuel taxes combined with high debt and weaker institutions.[8] Costa Rica, where transport taxes make up about 20% of government revenue, offers an example of forward planning: an IDB study estimated an average fiscal impact of decarbonisation of 0.41% of GDP a year over 2023–2050, and showed it could be offset through a mix of energy, property, import and distance-based taxes.[35]

The policy menu

Governments are using a combination of instruments, each with trade-offs between simplicity, fairness and durability.

Figure 5

The policy menu: how governments are responding

Main revenue responses to fuel-tax erosion, with examples

InstrumentExamplesTrade-offs
Flat annual EV registration feeUS: 41 states, US$50–270 a yearSimple and cheap to collect; unrelated to road use; can deter EV adoption
Per-km or per-mile charge for EVsUK eVED (planned, 2028); Iceland 2024; NZ 2024Links payment to use; needs mileage verification; privacy and cost questions
Per-km charge for all vehiclesIceland (2026); NZ (proposed, no date set)Fuel-neutral and durable; largest administrative and political change
Distance charges for heavy vehiclesGermany, Switzerland, BelgiumMature technology; targets the main source of pavement wear
Taxing electricity used for transportChina (electricity taxes almost fully offset its projected fuel-tax loss to 2030)Uses existing utility billing; hard to separate transport from other uses
Transfers from general revenueUS Highway Trust Fund: ~US$275bn since 2007Avoids new charges; breaks the user-pays link and competes with other spending
Sources: Tax Foundation 2026; HM Treasury and HMRC 2026; CiTTi 2026; NZ Ministry of Transport; German Federal Ministry of Transport 2026; IEA 2025; Eno Center 2025.[14][23][36][37][38][10][7] Trade-off assessment: AFRIHECOM.

Lessons for policymakers

  1. Plan before the erosion is visibleRevenue loss accumulates slowly and then accelerates. The UK committed to eVED years before receipts fall sharply; the US delayed and now faces projected insolvency.
  2. Address efficiency as well as electrificationIndexing rates to inflation and to vehicle efficiency protects revenue from both causes of erosion.
  3. Protect early adoptionPhased or discounted rates, such as the UK’s half-rate per-mile charge and New Zealand’s hybrid discount, balance fiscal and climate goals.
  4. Check legal feasibility earlyAustralia’s experience shows that the level of government imposing a charge can determine whether it survives.
  5. Keep administration simpleOdometer readings and existing registration systems keep collection costs low and privacy concerns manageable.
  6. Be transparent about use of revenuePublic acceptance improves when users can see the link between what they pay and the roads they use.

The fuel tax is not disappearing overnight, but its role as the backbone of road financing is ending. The countries that manage the transition best will be those that treat it as a design problem today rather than a fiscal crisis tomorrow.

References

  1. International Energy Agency. Global EV Outlook 2026: Executive summary. May 2026. iea.org
  2. International Energy Agency. Close to 30% of cars sold this year are set to be electric (press release). 20 May 2026. iea.org
  3. The Local / AFP. Norway closes in on goal of 100 percent electric car sales (OFV registration data). 2 January 2026. thelocal.com
  4. International Energy Agency. Global EV Outlook 2026: Trends in electric cars. May 2026. iea.org
  5. International Energy Agency. Global EV Outlook 2026: Trends in other EV modes. May 2026. iea.org
  6. International Transport Forum. Decarbonisation and the Pricing of Road Transport, Roundtable Report 191. OECD/ITF; 2023. itf-oecd.org
  7. Davis J (Eno Center for Transportation). Testimony to the Subcommittee on Highways and Transit, House Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure. 29 April 2025. house.gov
  8. Noll B, Schmidt TS, Egli F. The electric vehicle transition and vanishing fuel tax revenues. Nature Sustainability. 2026;9:207–211. doi:10.1038/s41893-025-01721-7. Record
  9. Noll B, Schmidt TS, Egli F. Bridging the fuel tax revenue gap in the move to electric mobility (policy brief). Nature Sustainability. 2026;9:192–193. nature.com
  10. International Energy Agency. Global EV Outlook 2025: Outlook for energy demand. May 2025. iea.org
  11. US Federal Highway Administration. When did the Federal Government begin collecting the gas tax? fhwa.dot.gov
  12. Congressional Research Service. The Highway Trust Fund (IF13064). Updated 2 July 2026. everycrsreport.com
  13. Congressional Budget Office. Baseline Projections: Highway Trust Fund Accounts. June 2026. cbo.gov; CBO presentation, 16 June 2026. cbo.gov
  14. Tax Foundation. Electric vehicle (EV) taxes by state. August 2026. taxfoundation.org
  15. Congressional Budget Office. The Highway Trust Fund (presentation slides). June 2026. cbo.gov
  16. ARTBA. Congress sends revised tax bill to President Trump for enactment. July 2025. artba.org
  17. Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget. Proposed EV fee could raise $30 billion. 2026. crfb.org
  18. Congressional Budget Office. Cost estimate and Highway Trust Fund effects of H.R. 8870, BUILD America 250 Act. July 2026. cbo.gov
  19. Holland & Knight. Beyond the midterms: Congress faces converging year-end deadlines. 9 October 2026. hklaw.com
  20. HM Revenue & Customs. Hydrocarbon Oils Bulletin commentary. Updated 31 July 2026. gov.uk
  21. Office for Budget Responsibility. Fuel duties (tax-by-tax explainer). obr.uk
  22. Office for Budget Responsibility. Updated electric vehicle assumptions and their fiscal implications (box, Economic and Fiscal Outlook). November 2023. obr.uk
  23. HM Treasury and HMRC. Electric Vehicle Excise Duty (eVED) (policy paper). 13 July 2026. gov.uk
  24. Vehicle Certification Agency. Electric Vehicle Excise Duty (eVED). gov.uk
  25. Office for Budget Responsibility. Economic and Fiscal Outlook. November 2025. obr.uk
  26. Government of Norway. Zero-emission vehicles (fact article). Updated 15 January 2025. regjeringen.no
  27. electrive. Norway to keep tax breaks for electric cars a little longer. 4 December 2025. electrive.com
  28. The Local Norway. The driving and transport changes to expect in Norway in 2026. 5 December 2025. thelocal.no
  29. Athlon. Coalitieakkoord 2026: plannen voor de auto. 3 February 2026. athlon.com; Mobiliteit.nl. Kabinet wil autobelastingen drastisch herzien. 14 July 2025. mobiliteit.nl
  30. VoxEU/CEPR. Implications of decarbonisation for fuel excise tax revenues and the pricing of road transport. 20 July 2024. cepr.org
  31. International Transport Forum. Taxation of transport in Slovenia (presentation). 2022. itf-oecd.org
  32. Wikipedia. Vanderstock v Victoria (summary of the ZLEV charge and High Court decision). wikipedia.org
  33. Allens. Constitutional cloud cast by High Court (Vanderstock v Victoria [2023] HCA 30). October 2023. allens.com.au; King & Wood Mallesons. High Court rules that Victoria’s electric vehicle charge is unconstitutional. mallesons.com
  34. University of Sydney Business School. Reforming Australian road pricing. 1 June 2026. sydney.edu.au
  35. Inter-American Development Bank. Policy options to mitigate the fiscal impact of road transport decarbonization: the case of Costa Rica. July 2021. iadb.org
  36. CiTTi Magazine. Iceland moves to nationwide fuel-neutral per-kilometre charging for all road vehicles. 13 January 2026. cittimagazine.co.uk
  37. New Zealand Ministry of Transport. Road User Charges system. transport.govt.nz
  38. German Federal Ministry of Transport (BMV). Lkw-Maut. February 2026. bmv.de

Figures are reported as published by each source and may differ in date, definition and currency. This article draws only on publicly available information.

Leave A Comment