logo
Low-Carbon Transport & E-Mobility

Road User Charging in Practice: Lessons from New Zealand, Iceland, Oregon and Utah

Distance-based charging has moved from theory to statute. The schemes that work share a few design choices: simple measurement, existing touchpoints, mandatory participation and a credible answer on privacy.

By AFRIHECOM Research Team24 October 202611 min read

Illustration: AFRIHECOM. Kilometre markers along a road: distance-based charging links what users pay to how much they use the network.

NZ$2.16bn
raised by New Zealand’s road user charges in 2025/26; RUC has exceeded fuel excise since 2024/25
NZTA, NLTF Annual Reports
1 Jan 2026
Iceland replaced fuel excise with a per-km charge on all vehicles
Government of Iceland
€13.4bn
raised by Germany’s distance-based truck toll in 2025
German Federal Ministry of Transport

Key takeaways

  • New Zealand has charged by distance since 1978; since 2024/25 RUC revenue has exceeded fuel excise.[6][7]
  • Iceland moved from per-km charges on EVs (2024) to all vehicles (2026), replacing fuel excise.[13]
  • Voluntary US programmes stayed small; Oregon and Hawaii are now making per-mile charges mandatory for EVs (and, in Oregon, hybrids).[18][28]
  • Collection costs fall sharply with scale and low-tech measurement, from about 76% in Utah’s small scheme to an estimated 2–4% using existing inspections.[26][1]
  • US evidence suggests rural households would not be disadvantaged by distance charging.[39][40]

Fuel taxes are among the cheapest taxes to collect, at around 1% of revenue in a typical US state,[1] but they tie road revenue to fuel consumption rather than road use. As vehicles become more efficient and electric, governments are testing a direct alternative: charging for distance travelled. This article examines the schemes with the longest operating records and the most recent reforms, and what their experience implies for scheme design.

New Zealand: the world’s longest-running road user charge

New Zealand has charged road users by distance since 1978. Today, diesel vehicles, heavy vehicles over 3.5 tonnes (heavy EVs are exempt until 1 July 2027) and, since 1 April 2024, light electric vehicles and plug-in hybrids pay road user charges (RUC); petrol vehicles pay fuel excise instead.[2][3] Light EVs pay NZ$76 per 1,000 km (including GST). Plug-in hybrids pay NZ$38, a 50% discount reflecting the fuel excise they also pay.[4] Users buy licences in 1,000 km blocks, verified by odometer or, for heavy vehicles, hubodometer, and electronic RUC providers already serve about half the heavy fleet.[5]

The fiscal significance is now clear. Gross RUC revenue in the National Land Transport Fund first exceeded fuel excise in 2024/25 (NZ$2,082m against NZ$1,999m) and did so again in 2025/26 (NZ$2,155m against NZ$2,034m).[6][7]

Figure 1

In New Zealand, distance charges now raise more than fuel excise

Gross National Land Transport Fund revenue, NZ$ million

Fuel excise dutyRoad user charges
Fuel excise duty2024/25
1,999
Road user charges2024/25
2,082
Fuel excise duty2025/26
2,034
Road user charges2025/26
2,155
Sources: NZ Transport Agency, NLTF Annual Reports 2024/25 and 2025/26.[6][7] Road user charges were about 47% of gross land transport revenue in both years (AFRIHECOM calculation). Motor vehicle registration and licensing added NZ$288m and NZ$403m.
View the data as a table
Revenue line2024/252025/26
Fuel excise duty1,9992,034
Road user charges2,0822,155
Registration and licensing288403

The government is now preparing to move all light vehicles, about 3.5 million, onto electronic RUC, described by the minister as the biggest change to the system in 50 years.[5] Cabinet agreed to allow digital licences, post-pay billing and bundling with tolls,[5] and a bill introduced in November 2025 provides for in-vehicle distance recording and alternative payment models such as post-payment.[8][9] Fuel excise would be abolished once petrol vehicles transfer; odometer reporting would remain available and the 2012 Act’s privacy safeguards would extend to all providers.[9] As of late September 2026 the bill had not completed its parliamentary stages, and Cabinet is to consider the transition date for petrol vehicles in 2027.[10][9]

Iceland: from electric vehicles to every vehicle in two years

Iceland introduced a per-kilometre charge on electric and hydrogen cars (6 ISK/km) and plug-in hybrids (2 ISK/km) on 1 January 2024, citing falling revenue as efficient vehicles paid less through fuel taxes.[11] More than 40,000 odometer registrations were made within three weeks.[12] From 1 January 2026 the charge was extended to all vehicles, replacing fuel excise on petrol and diesel, with 29 weight classes ranging from 6.95 ISK/km for cars to 45.17 ISK/km for the heaviest vehicles, and a carbon tax increase of about 25%.[13][14] According to trade press, road-use revenue per kilometre had fallen by about 43% between 2006 and 2023.[15]

Figure 2

Iceland’s new kilometre charge scales steeply with vehicle weight

Per-kilometre charge by permitted gross weight, from 1 January 2026, ISK per km

Motorcycles and light vehicles
4.15
Up to 3,500 kgmost cars
6.95
3,501–5,000 kg
9.85
10,001–11,000 kg
13.98
31,001 kg and overheaviest class
45.17
Sources: Government bill (Þingskjal 147, 2025–26); Skatturinn.[13][14] Selected classes of 29 shown. The reform replaced fuel excise on petrol and diesel and raised the carbon tax by about 25%; transitional reduced rates apply to coaches and trailers in 2026–27 and to zero-emission heavy vehicles (20% of the rate) in 2026–29.
View the data as a table
Weight classISK per km
Motorcycles and light vehicles4.15
0–3,500 kg6.95
3,501–5,000 kg9.85
10,001–11,000 kg13.98
31,001 kg and over45.17

Iceland’s design is deliberately low-tech: odometer readings submitted through a government app or taken at vehicle inspection, provisional monthly billing and annual true-ups. Non-reporting triggers a default estimate of 60 km per day for individuals, and unpaid charges become a lien on the vehicle.[14][13]

The schemes that reached scale did so by making participation mandatory and measurement simple, not by perfecting the technology first.

Oregon and Utah: voluntary pilots, mandatory futures

Oregon launched OReGO in July 2015 at 1.5 US¢ per mile, with 801 volunteers in its first month.[16] The rate is now 2 US¢ per mile, with a credit for fuel tax paid;[17] under 2025 legislation it is set at 5% of the per-gallon fuel tax.[18] Enrolment has stayed at about 1,000 vehicles,[19] and the voluntary programme has not yet generated net revenue.[20] Oregon’s task force notes that the fuel tax is extremely cheap to collect while road usage charging is significantly more expensive, and assumes costs fall to 20% of gross revenue over time.[21]

The 2025 legislation (HB 3991) makes per-mile charging mandatory for electric vehicles and hybrids, phased in from July 2027 to July 2028, with a flat annual alternative of US$340, and caps the share of revenue private account managers may retain at 10% from 2030.[18] About 600,000 vehicles are expected in the mandatory programme.[19] In May 2026 voters rejected the same law’s fuel tax, payroll tax and fee increases in Referendum 120 by 83% to 17%, but the road usage charge provisions were not referred and proceed.[22] Oregon projects that fuel-efficiency gains will reduce fuel tax revenue by a cumulative US$2.0bn through 2035.[23]

Utah has run an opt-in road usage charge since 2020, with the annual charge capped at the alternative-fuel registration fee. In 2026 the rate is 1.25 US¢ per mile with a US$180 cap, rising to 1.5 US¢ and US$280 in 2027, then indexed to inflation.[24] Enrolment reached 11,288 vehicles by November 2025, about 18% of Utah’s EVs, with reporting split roughly evenly between odometer readings and telematics.[25] In FY2025 revenue exceeded administration costs for the first time.[26] Utah’s figures show how strongly costs depend on method: about US$7 per user per year for odometer photos against about US$38 for telematics.[25]

Figure 3

Voluntary schemes have struggled to reach scale

Vehicles enrolled in US road usage charge programmes, latest figure

Virginia Mileage ChoiceDec 2025; ≈1% of highway-use-fee payers
≈25,000
Utah RUCNov 2025; 18% of registered EVs
11,288
Oregon OReGOSep 2026; after 11 years
≈1,000
Sources: Virginia DMV 2026; UDOT 2025; Oregon DOT 2026.[27][25][19] By contrast, Iceland’s mandatory scheme received more than 40,000 odometer registrations within three weeks of launch in January 2024.[12]
View the data as a table
ProgrammeEnrolledDate
Virginia Mileage Choice≈25,000Dec 2025
Utah RUC11,288Nov 2025
Oregon OReGO≈1,000Sep 2026

The schemes now operating differ widely in rate design and measurement method, as the comparison below shows.

Figure 4

Light-vehicle distance charges compared

Current rates in local currency, with measurement method and status

SchemeRateHow distance is measuredStatus
New Zealand, light EVNZ$76 per 1,000 kmPrepaid 1,000 km licences; odometer or electronic RUCSince April 2024
New Zealand, plug-in hybridNZ$38 per 1,000 kmAs above; 50% discount reflects fuel excise also paidSince April 2024
Iceland, vehicles up to 3.5 t6.95 ISK per kmOdometer readings via app or inspectionAll vehicles since January 2026
Oregon, USA2.0 US¢ per mileCertified account managers; non-GPS optionVoluntary since 2015; mandatory for EVs from 2027
Utah, USA1.25 US¢ per mile (cap US$180)Odometer photo or telematics; no location dataOpt-in since 2020; 2026 rate
Hawaii, USA0.8 US¢ per mile (cap US$50)Odometer at annual safety inspectionMandatory for EVs from July 2028
Sources: NZ Ministry of Transport; Skatturinn; Oregon DOT; Utah Code; Hawaii RUC programme.[4][14][17][24][28] Rates are not converted to a common currency because exchange rates vary over time.

Elsewhere in the United States, Virginia’s Mileage Choice programme had about 25,000 participants by December 2025, roughly 1% of the 2 million vehicles that pay its highway use fee and under 0.5% of all registered vehicles.[27] Hawaii will make per-mile charging mandatory for EVs from July 2028, using odometer readings taken at the existing annual safety inspection.[28]

The cost of collection

Administration cost is the most frequently cited weakness of road user charging. The evidence shows it is largely a function of scale and design. Hawaii’s analysis estimated 2–4% of revenue if existing inspection and registry systems are used, against 15–25% for third-party plug-in devices.[1] A UC Davis analysis for California estimated about 3% of motor fuel tax revenue,[29] while a preliminary Eastern Corridor Coalition estimate, reported in the federal STSFA evaluation, put costs at about 18% of gross revenue, assuming about one million customers.[30] New Zealand’s tolling, by comparison, has cost slightly more than 30% of scheme revenue on average.[31]

Figure 5

The cost of collection falls with scale and simplicity

Administration and collection cost as a share of revenue, %

Fuel tax, typical US statebenchmark range 1–3%
1–3%
Hawaii RUC using existing inspectionestimate
2–4%
California RUC, statewideestimate
≈3%
Washington pilot, manual reporting
7–8%
Washington pilot, automated
12–13%
Eastern Corridor Coalition estimateassumes ≈1 million users (via FHWA)
≈18%
Oregon OReGO, voluntaryas reported in 2022
≈40%
Utah RUC, FY2025≈9,700 users (July 2025)
≈76%
020406080
Higher cost share →
Sources: Hawaii DOT 2022; UC Davis 2024; FHWA STSFA evaluation; Utah legislative staff 2025; UDOT 2025.[1][29][30][26][25] Utah’s share is AFRIHECOM’s calculation from about US$291,000 of administration cost and US$384,000 of revenue; UDOT projects 7.5% at 50,000 users. California’s figure is back-office cost relative to motor fuel tax revenue. Estimates use different definitions and are indicative.
View the data as a table
Scheme or estimateCost as % of revenue
Fuel tax, typical US1–3
Hawaii, inspection-based (est.)2–4
California (est.)≈3
Washington pilot, manual7–8
Washington pilot, automated12–13
Eastern Corridor Coalition (est., ≈1m users)≈18
Oregon OReGO (2022)≈40
Utah FY2025 (calc.)≈76
Utah at 50,000 users (proj.)7.5

Heavy vehicles: where distance charging is already mature

For heavy vehicles, weight-distance charging is established practice. Switzerland’s heavy vehicle fee, approved by referendum in 1998 and in force since 2001, raised about CHF 1.8bn in 2024, with two-thirds going to the federal government, mostly for rail.[32][33] Between 2001 and 2005, truck-kilometres fell 6.4% while tonne-kilometres rose 16.4%, reflecting both the fee and higher weight limits.[32] Electric and hydrogen trucks will become liable from 2031, with discounts tapering from 70% to 10% by 2035 and ending in 2036.[34]

Germany’s truck toll raised about €13.4bn in 2025. It added a CO2 component in December 2023, priced at €200 per tonne of CO2, and extended to vehicles over 3.5 tonnes in July 2024; zero-emission heavy vehicles are exempt until mid-2031.[35][36] Belgium’s kilometre charge passed €1bn in 2024.[37] EU rules adopted in 2022 require CO2-differentiated truck charges and the phase-out of time-based vignettes on the core network by 2030, with exceptions.[38]

Figure 6

Heavy-vehicle distance charging is mature and lucrative

Selected weight-distance charging schemes for heavy vehicles

SchemeSinceScope and designAnnual revenue
Switzerland, LSVA/HVF2001Vehicles >3.5 t, all roads; per tonne-km; tachograph-linked unitCHF 1.8bn (2024)
Germany, Lkw-Maut2005Vehicles >3.5 t (since July 2024) on motorways and federal roads; CO2 component since Dec 2023€13.4bn (2025)
Belgium, Viapass2016Vehicles >3.5 t; distance-based kilometre charge€1.016bn (2024)
New Zealand, RUC (vehicles >3.5 t; heavy EVs exempt to July 2027)1978Weight and axle-based; hubodometers or electronic RUCNZ$2.16bn total RUC (2025/26)
Sources: ARE 2015; Swiss Federal Council 2025; BMV 2026; electrive 2023; NewMobility News 2025; NZTA 2026.[32][33][35][36][37][7]

Privacy and equity

Privacy concerns have shaped every scheme. The most successful designs avoid location tracking altogether: Iceland and Hawaii rely on odometer readings, New Zealand keeps telematics optional, and Utah collects mileage totals only, with no location data.[14][28][9][25]

On equity, the common assumption that rural drivers lose under distance charging is not supported by the US evidence. A RUC West analysis found rural households would pay about 1.9–6.3% less under a revenue-neutral charge, because their vehicles tend to be older and less fuel-efficient.[39] A California study found that switching would shift the burden slightly from rural to urban and from lower- to higher-income households (except low-income urban households, whose costs would rise slightly), with changes of less than US$1 a week for every group.[40] The ITF recommends targeted assistance over blanket exemptions.[41]

Design lessons

  1. Use existing touchpointsVehicle inspection, licensing and registration systems can capture odometer readings at low cost, as in Iceland and Hawaii.
  2. Keep a low-tech optionOdometer-based reporting answers privacy concerns and costs a fraction of telematics. Technology can be optional, not required.
  3. Make it mandatory for a defined groupVoluntary programmes have stayed small. Every scheme that reached scale defined who must pay and when.
  4. Start with heavy vehicles and new technologiesWeight-distance charging for heavy vehicles and per-km charges for EVs are proven entry points before economy-wide reform.
  5. Plan the political sequenceNew Zealand and Iceland legislated transparently over several years; Oregon shows how bundling charges with tax rises can provoke backlash.
  6. Build in indexation and reviewRates linked to inflation or fuel tax equivalents, with scheduled reviews, avoid the slow real-terms erosion that undermines fuel taxes.

Distance-based charging is no longer experimental. The question for policymakers is not whether it can work, but how to design it so that it is cheap to run, acceptable to the public and fair across users.

References

  1. Hawaii Department of Transportation. RUC Cost Analysis. February 2022. hiruc.org
  2. New Zealand Ministry of Transport. Road User Charges system. transport.govt.nz
  3. New Zealand Ministry of Transport. Rates of petrol excise duty and road user charges. transport.govt.nz
  4. New Zealand Ministry of Transport. Official Information Act response OC240186 (RUC rates for light EVs and PHEVs). 25 March 2024. transport.govt.nz
  5. Hon Chris Bishop. Next steps on replacing petrol tax. 6 August 2025. national.org.nz; RNZ. Road user charges for all vehicles move a step closer. 6 August 2025. rnz.co.nz
  6. NZ Transport Agency Waka Kotahi. National Land Transport Fund Annual Report 2024/25. October 2025. nzta.govt.nz
  7. NZ Transport Agency Waka Kotahi. National Land Transport Fund Annual Report 2025/26. September 2026. nzta.govt.nz
  8. New Zealand Government. Modernising road funding. 13 November 2025. beehive.govt.nz
  9. New Zealand Ministry of Transport. Transitioning all vehicles to road user charges: FAQs. November 2025. transport.govt.nz
  10. Waipā District Council. Radar: legislation tracker, September 2026 (status of the Land Transport (Revenue) Amendment Bill). waipadc.govt.nz
  11. Iceland Monitor (mbl.is). New fee based on per-kilometre usage. 4 October 2023. icelandmonitor.mbl.is
  12. Digital Iceland. 80% have registered kilometer status on Ísland.is. 19 January 2024. island.is
  13. Althingi. Government bill on kilometre charges (Þingskjal 147, 157th legislative session, 2025–26). samband.is
  14. Skatturinn (Iceland Revenue and Customs). Kílómetragjald (kilometre charge rates and rules). skatturinn.is
  15. CiTTi Magazine. Iceland moves to nationwide fuel-neutral per-kilometre charging for all road vehicles. 13 January 2026. cittimagazine.co.uk
  16. Equipment World. Oregon’s pay-as-you-drive usage tax program gathers 801 volunteers in first month. 7 August 2015. equipmentworld.com
  17. Oregon Department of Transportation. OReGO: Oregon’s Road Usage Charge Program. oregon.gov
  18. Oregon Legislative Fiscal Office. Fiscal impact statement, HB 3991-A (2025 special session). oregonlegislature.gov
  19. Oregon Department of Transportation. Update on OReGO mandatory road usage charge project implementation (Road User Fee Task Force). September 2026. oregon.gov
  20. Governing. Oregon’s new EV road fee exempts the biggest commercial fleets. 12 June 2026. governing.com
  21. Oregon Road User Fee Task Force. 2024 Report. oregon.gov
  22. Ballotpedia. Oregon Referendum 120, Increase to Gas Tax, Payroll Tax, and Vehicle Registration Fees Referendum (May 2026). ballotpedia.org
  23. Oregon Department of Transportation. Road User Fee Task Force background and mandatory road usage charge legislation. 24 September 2026. oregon.gov
  24. Utah Code §72-1-213.1, Road usage charge program (as amended by HB 481, 2026). le.utah.gov
  25. Utah Department of Transportation. Road Usage Charge: presentation to Minnesota policy makers. 15 December 2025. lcc.mn.gov
  26. Utah Office of Legislative Research and General Counsel. Road Usage Charge Program. 15 September 2025. le.utah.gov
  27. Virginia DMV (S. Cummings). Virginia Mileage Choice Program overview, presentation to the Vermont Legislature. January 2026. legislature.vermont.gov
  28. Hawaii Road Usage Charge programme. hiruc.org; US DOE Alternative Fuels Data Center, Hawaii EV registration fee and road usage charge. afdc.energy.gov
  29. UC Davis Institute of Transportation Studies. Road charge cost analysis, presentation to the California Road Charge Technical Advisory Committee. May 2024. catc.ca.gov
  30. US Federal Highway Administration. Surface Transportation System Funding Alternatives (STSFA) Phase I evaluation, chapter 3. fhwa.dot.gov
  31. New Zealand Ministry of Transport. Proactive release: Roads of National Significance tolling briefing. 2025. transport.govt.nz
  32. Swiss Federal Office for Spatial Development (ARE). Fair and efficient: the distance-related heavy vehicle fee (HVF) in Switzerland. January 2015. are.admin.ch
  33. Swiss Federal Council. Press release on the heavy vehicle fee. 28 May 2025. admin.ch
  34. electrive. Schweiz: E-Lkw-Maut ab 2031. 6 October 2026. electrive.net
  35. German Federal Ministry of Transport (BMV). Lkw-Maut. February 2026. bmv.de
  36. electrive. Lkw-Maut mit CO2-Aufschlag wird in Deutschland wirksam. 1 December 2023. electrive.net
  37. NewMobility News. Km tax for trucks in Belgium brings in more than a billion for the first time. 8 January 2025. newmobility.news
  38. European Commission. Greening road transport: EU adopts new road charging rules. 18 February 2022. ec.europa.eu; Transport & Environment. Eurovignette briefing update. March 2024. transportenvironment.org
  39. US Federal Highway Administration. STSFA Phase I evaluation, chapter 7 (equity and public acceptance). fhwa.dot.gov
  40. Speroni S, Agrawal AW, Manville M, Taylor BD. Charging Drivers by the Gallon vs. the Mile: An Equity Analysis by Geography and Income in California. Mineta Transportation Institute; September 2022. transweb.sjsu.edu
  41. International Transport Forum. The Social Impacts of Road Pricing, Roundtable Report 170. OECD/ITF; 2018. itf-oecd.org

Figures are reported as published by each source and may differ in date and definition. Currency values are not converted. This article draws only on publicly available information.

Leave A Comment