Who Should Pay for the Road? Vehicle Weight, Road Wear and Fairness in the EV Transition
Road damage rises steeply with axle load, so the heaviest vehicles cause most pavement wear. Electric vehicles add weight, but the evidence shows trucks, not cars, remain the issue. That has direct implications for how road charges are designed.
Illustration: AFRIHECOM. A heavy truck pressing down on the layers of a road pavement beside a car: axle load, not vehicle type, drives road wear.
Key takeaways
- Pavement damage rises roughly with the fourth power of axle load, and faster on weak pavements.[2][3]
- Heavy vehicles account for the vast majority of pavement wear; cars cause negligible damage.[6][8]
- EVs are heavier, but their pavement effect remains negligible compared with trucks; heavy e-trucks need attention.[8][15]
- Under the 1990s US federal fee structure, the heaviest trucks were projected to pay about half their costs; axle-weight-distance charges would largely correct this.[17]
- Heavier EVs may emit slightly more fine non-exhaust particles, now being regulated under Euro 7.[26][27]
As road financing systems are redesigned for an electrified fleet, an old question returns: what does each vehicle actually cost the road? The answer matters for fairness and efficiency. If charges do not reflect the damage vehicles cause, some users subsidise others and the incentives to protect pavements are weakened. This article reviews what pavement engineering and cost allocation studies tell us, and how the arrival of heavier electric vehicles changes the picture.
The physics of pavement damage
Modern understanding of road wear traces back to the AASHO Road Test near Ottawa, Illinois, where test traffic ran from October 1958 to November 1960 over 836 pavement sections.[1] From it came the concept of the equivalent single axle load (ESAL), defined as one pass of an 80 kN (18,000 lb) single axle, and the finding that damage rises roughly with the fourth power of axle load.[2] Doubling an axle’s load does not double damage; it multiplies it about sixteen-fold.
Small increases in axle load cause large increases in damage
Relative pavement damage per axle pass under the fourth-power approximation (standard 8.16 t axle = 1)
View the data as a table
| Axle load | Relative damage (exponent 2) | Exponent 4 | Exponent 6 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 t | 0.015 | 0.0002 | 0.000003 |
| 4 t | 0.24 | 0.058 | 0.014 |
| 6 t | 0.54 | 0.29 | 0.16 |
| 8.16 t | 1 | 1 | 1 |
| 10 t | 1.50 | 2.26 | 3.39 |
| 11.5 t | 1.99 | 3.94 | 7.83 |
| 13 t | 2.54 | 6.44 | 16.4 |
The “fourth power law” is an approximation, not a constant. A reanalysis of the AASHO data by the UK’s Transport and Road Research Laboratory found effective exponents from 2.4 to 6.6, with the highest values on weak pavements under heavy wheel loads, concluding that overloading weak pavements is more serious than the fourth-power law implies.[3] Later research found that some low-volume pavements cannot be described by any simple power law,[4] while a test track in Zimbabwe found exponents that were variable but all below the 4.2 that road designers in developing countries commonly use.[5] The direction is consistent, even if the exponent varies: heavy axles dominate pavement damage.
Trucks, not cars, wear out roads
The practical consequence is stark. New Zealand’s Ministry of Transport attributes about 93% of pavement wear costs to heavy vehicles that account for about 7% of powered vehicle-kilometres.[6] US federal analysis estimated the marginal pavement cost of a five-axle, 80,000 lb truck on urban Interstates at 40.9 cents per mile, against 0.1 cents for a car.[7] A 2025 study for the California Transportation Commission calculated, using the fourth-power rule, that about 1,255 passes of the heaviest axle of the heaviest Tesla car (3,360 lb) equal one pass of a 20,000 lb legal truck axle, and concluded that cars cause insignificant pavement damage.[8]
The pavement cost of a truck-mile dwarfs that of a car-mile
Marginal pavement cost on urban Interstate highways, US cents per vehicle-mile (2000)
View the data as a table
| Vehicle | Rural Interstate (¢/mile) | Urban Interstate (¢/mile) |
|---|---|---|
| Autos | 0 | 0.1 |
| 4-axle single unit, 60 kip | 5.6 | 18.1 |
| 5-axle combination, 80 kip | 12.7 | 40.9 |
Electric cars are heavier, but in pavement terms they remain in a different universe from trucks.
Are electric vehicles different?
Electric cars are heavier than comparable conventional cars, mainly because of their batteries. One analysis of 355 EV models found a mean weight of 2,133 kg, against about 1,500 kg for the average UK car.[9] At the extremes, the electric Ford F-150 Lightning is up to 35% heavier than its petrol equivalent, and the GMC Hummer EV’s battery alone weighs 2,923 lb (about 1,326 kg).[10][11] The US EPA confirms that battery-electric and plug-in hybrid vehicles are heavier than their conventional counterparts in each vehicle type, but finds that the long-run rise in average vehicle weight has been driven mainly by the shift from cars to SUVs.[12] Large models, SUVs and pickups accounted for about three-quarters of US battery-electric car sales in 2023.[13]
Electric cars are heavier, but still far from truck territory
Curb weight, kilograms (lines show reported ranges)
View the data as a table
| Vehicle | Weight (kg) |
|---|---|
| Average UK car | ≈1,500 |
| Average EV model (355 models) | 2,133 |
| Ford F-150 Lightning | 2,728–3,127 |
| GMC Hummer EV | ≈4,111 |
Does the extra weight matter for roads? For cars, the evidence says very little. The California study concluded that heavier cars and light trucks will continue to have a very minor effect on pavement damage and maintenance costs.[8] A widely reported newspaper analysis (the Telegraph, with University of Leeds data) estimated that electric cars impose about 2.2 times the fourth-power “stress” of their petrol equivalents,[14] but even a doubling of a negligible number remains negligible relative to a single truck axle.
Heavy electric trucks are a different matter. Research for the Illinois Center for Transportation found that the higher loads and acceleration of heavy electric trucks increase critical pavement strains and shorten pavement life, with thin asphalt sections most affected by the extra load.[15] The European Union is also revising its weights and dimensions rules: in December 2025 the Council agreed a position allowing zero-emission combinations up to 4 tonnes more (from 40 to 44 tonnes for six-axle combinations) to offset battery weight, with negotiations with the European Parliament continuing.[16]
Who pays what?
Cost allocation studies compare what each vehicle class pays in user charges with the costs it imposes. The US federal study of 1997 projected that, under the then-current federal user-fee structure (mainly fuel taxes, plus truck excise, tyre and heavy-vehicle use taxes), cars would pay roughly their share in 2000, while the heaviest combination trucks would pay only about half of the costs they caused. Passenger vehicles accounted for 93% of travel and paid 64% of federal user fees. The study found that an axle-weight-distance tax would bring all truck weight classes to about 1.0 (cars 0.9), although buses would still underpay and pickups and vans overpay.[17]
Under the 1990s US fee structure, the heaviest trucks were projected to pay about half their road costs
Ratio of federal user fees paid to highway costs caused, by vehicle class (1.0 = pays its share), US 1997 study
View the data as a table
| Vehicle class | Equity ratio |
|---|---|
| Passenger cars | 1.0 |
| Pickups and vans | 1.4 |
| Buses | 0.1 |
| Single-unit trucks <25,000 lb | 1.5 |
| Single-unit trucks >50,000 lb | 0.5 |
| Combinations 70–75,000 lb | 1.0 |
| Combinations 80–100,000 lb | 0.6 |
| Combinations >100,000 lb | 0.5 |
Results depend on each jurisdiction’s tax structure. Oregon, which already levies a weight-mile tax on heavy trucks, projected in its 2025–27 study that light vehicles would underpay by about 11% and heavy vehicles overpay by about 26%.[18]
Charging instruments that reflect damage
Several countries price heavy-vehicle road use directly by weight and distance. New Zealand’s road user charges include more than 80 rates, from about NZ$72 to more than NZ$600 per 1,000 km, set by weight band and axle configuration.[19] Switzerland’s heavy vehicle fee is based on kilometres driven, maximum permissible weight and emission class.[20] Germany’s truck toll separately prices infrastructure, air pollution, noise and CO2.[21] EU rules now require CO2-differentiated truck charges and a mandatory air-pollution external-cost charge from March 2026,[22] and member states may exempt or discount zero-emission heavy vehicles until mid-2031.[23]
Germany’s truck toll prices four different costs
Toll rate per km for a Euro 6 truck over 18 t with five or more axles, CO₂ class 1, from 1 July 2024 (euro cents per km; total 34.8)
View the data as a table
| Component | ct/km |
|---|---|
| Infrastructure | 15.5 |
| Air pollution | 2.3 |
| Noise | 1.2 |
| CO2 | 15.8 |
| Total | 34.8 |
Administration of weight-distance taxes need not be costly: the US Congressional Budget Office reported administrative costs of about US$20 per truck per year for Oregon’s weight-mile tax.[25]
A new frontier: non-exhaust emissions
Weight also matters for air quality. The OECD found that wear from tyres, brakes and road surfaces accounted for about 51% of road transport PM10 and 34% of PM2.5 in the EU in 2014. Electric vehicles emit an estimated 4–19% less non-exhaust PM10 per km than conventional cars, but heavier, long-range EVs may emit slightly more fine particles (PM2.5).[26] The EU’s Euro 7 regulation introduces limits on brake particle emissions, with stricter limits for pure EVs initially and a common 3 mg/km limit for cars and vans from 2035, and tyre abrasion limits from 2028.[27]
EVs cut exhaust to zero, but weight affects tyre, brake and road-wear particles
Non-exhaust particulate emissions of EVs relative to conventional cars, % change
View the data as a table
| Case | PM10 | PM2.5 |
|---|---|---|
| Lightweight EV | −18 to −19% | −11 to −13% |
| Heavier EV | −4 to −7% | +3 to +8% |
Implications for developing countries
Where pavements are thinner and overloading is more common, the stakes are higher. The TRRL reanalysis warned that overloading weak pavements is more damaging than the fourth-power law suggests,[3] and an early US government review concluded that strict enforcement of weight limits could nearly eliminate damage caused by overweight trucks.[28] Axle-load control is therefore not a technical detail but one of the most cost-effective road maintenance policies available.
Equity considerations
Distributional analyses suggest that switching from fuel taxes to distance charges changes the burden less than often assumed. CBO found that a truck mileage tax would have a distributional pattern across income groups similar to the diesel tax,[25] and a RAND analysis found a flat mileage fee to be about as regressive as fuel taxes.[29] Fairness depends more on rate design, including differentiation by weight, than on the choice of base alone.
Principles for charge design
- Charge heavy vehicles by weight and distanceAxle-weight-distance charging is the instrument best aligned with pavement damage, and is proven at scale in New Zealand, Switzerland and Germany.
- Do not penalise EV cars for road wearThe extra weight of electric cars has a negligible pavement effect; any car charge should be framed around road use and fiscal sustainability, not damage.
- Plan for heavier zero-emission trucksAllowances for battery weight should be matched by charges and pavement design that reflect the additional axle loads.
- Enforce axle-load limitsOn weaker networks, preventing overloading may save more than any change in charging structure.
- Price external costs explicitlySeparating infrastructure, pollution, noise and CO2 components, as Germany does, makes charges transparent and adjustable.
- Update cost allocation regularlyAs fleets change, periodic cost allocation studies keep charges fair and defensible.
The shift to electric vehicles is an opportunity to rebuild road charging on firmer ground: charges that reflect how much each vehicle uses and wears the network, rather than how much fuel it happens to burn.
References
- US Federal Highway Administration. The AASHO Road Test: Living Legacy for Highway Pavements. fhwa.dot.gov
- US Federal Highway Administration. Comprehensive Truck Size and Weight Study, Working Paper 3: Pavement. c.1994. fhwa.dot.gov
- Addis RR, Whitmarsh RA. Relative Damaging Power of Wheel Loads in Mixed Traffic. TRRL Laboratory Report LR979. 1981. trl.co.uk
- Dawson A. Rut accumulation and power law models for low-volume pavements under mixed traffic. Transportation Research Record. 2008;2068:78–86. sagepub.com
- Mitchell RL, Grant MP. The experimental determination of axle load factor exponents for thin flexible pavements in Zimbabwe. Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Bearing Capacity of Roads and Airfields, Trondheim; 1990:757–767. trid.trb.org
- New Zealand Ministry of Transport. Background to the road user charges (RUC) system. January 2022. transport.govt.nz
- US Federal Highway Administration. Addendum to the 1997 Federal Highway Cost Allocation Study Final Report. May 2000. fhwa.dot.gov
- Harvey JT. Preparation of the Vehicle Weight Safety Study Academic Report (Agreement CTC-C-25-008, Task 7). California Transportation Commission; 29 August 2025. catc.ca.gov
- Ritchie H. The weighty issue of electric cars. Sustainability by Numbers; 17 July 2023. substack.com
- Wikipedia. Ford F-150 Lightning (curb weight and comparison with petrol F-150). wikipedia.org; The Drive. Electric Ford F-150 Lightning’s battery weighs over 1,800 pounds by itself. 18 May 2021. thedrive.com
- The Drive. The 2022 GMC Hummer EV’s battery alone weighs 2,923 pounds. 15 February 2022. thedrive.com
- US Environmental Protection Agency. The 2025 EPA Automotive Trends Report. February 2026. epa.gov
- International Energy Agency. Global EV Outlook 2024: Trends in electric cars. 2024. iea.org
- WardsAuto. BEV era could produce potholes aplenty (reporting a Telegraph/University of Leeds analysis). 22 August 2023. wardsauto.com
- Jayme A, Hernandez JA, Al-Qadi IL, Cardenas, Hafeez, Villamil. Impact of Heavy Commercial Electric Vehicles on Flexible Pavements (FHWA-ICT-25-003). Illinois Center for Transportation; 1 May 2025. rosap.ntl.bts.gov
- Council of the European Union. Weights and Dimensions Directive revision: general approach (ST 15611/25). 4 December 2025. consilium.europa.eu; European Parliament. Legislative Train: Revision of the Weights and Dimensions Directive. europarl.europa.eu
- US Federal Highway Administration. 1997 Federal Highway Cost Allocation Study, summary report, Table 20 and user fee shares. fhwa.dot.gov; user fees
- ECONorthwest for Oregon DAS. Highway Cost Allocation Study 2025–27 (corrected). May 2025. oregon.gov
- New Zealand Ministry of Transport. Methodology used for road user charges rates. transport.govt.nz
- Swiss Federal Office for Customs and Border Security (BAZG). Heavy vehicle charge (LSVA): general information and tariffs. admin.ch
- Toll Collect. Toll rates as of 1 July 2024. toll-collect.de
- Directive (EU) 2022/362 amending Directives 1999/62/EC, 1999/37/EC and (EU) 2019/520 as regards the charging of vehicles for the use of certain infrastructures. eur-lex.europa.eu
- Directive (EU) 2025/2459 (extension of reduced charges and exemptions for zero-emission heavy-duty vehicles). November 2025. eur-lex.europa.eu
- Toll Collect. Toll exemption for zero-emission trucks extended to 30 June 2031 (news). toll-collect.de
- Congressional Budget Office. Issues and Options for a Tax on Vehicle Miles Traveled by Commercial Trucks. October 2019. cbo.gov
- OECD. Non-exhaust Particulate Emissions from Road Transport: An Ignored Environmental Policy Challenge. Paris: OECD; 2020. doi:10.1787/4a4dc6ca-en. oecd.org
- Regulation (EU) 2024/1257 (Euro 7). Official Journal of the European Union, 8 May 2024. eur-lex.europa.eu
- US General Accounting Office. Excessive Truck Weight: An Expensive Burden We Can No Longer Support (CED-79-94). 16 July 1979. gao.gov
- Weatherford BA. Mileage-Based User Fee Winners and Losers: An Analysis of the Distributional Implications of Taxing Vehicle Miles Traveled. RAND Pardee Graduate School, RGSD-295; 2012. rand.org
Figures are reported as published by each source and may differ in date and definition. Relative damage calculations are illustrative. This article draws only on publicly available information.
