Africa’s Second-Generation Road Funds: What Three Decades of Dedicated Maintenance Financing Have Taught Us
In the 1990s, African governments pioneered a model for financing road maintenance through user charges managed by independent boards. Thirty years on, the evidence shows real gains, persistent gaps and a model now facing new pressures.
Illustration: AFRIHECOM. Road maintenance under way on a damaged road: dedicated financing aims to keep roads in good condition before costly rehabilitation is needed.
Key takeaways
- Road funds spread rapidly from the 1990s; at least 27 Sub-Saharan African countries had one by 2006.[7]
- Funds improved maintenance financing, but only about one-third met routine needs in 2005.[6]
- Fuel levies have fallen well behind requirements in real terms: an average of about 9 US cents per litre in 2017.[16]
- Deferring maintenance multiplies costs: rehabilitation costs three to five times timely maintenance.[2]
- Recent reforms in Uganda and Ethiopia re-centralise road financing, while Tanzania now routes fuel levy collections directly to sector funds.[26][27][28]
By the late 1980s, much of Africa’s road network was deteriorating faster than it could be rebuilt. Heggie estimated in 1995 that nearly a third of the US$150 billion invested in African roads had been eroded through lack of maintenance, and that insufficient maintenance was costing the region about US$1.2 billion a year, around 0.85% of GDP.[1] A World Bank study across 85 countries had found that timely preventive maintenance of under US$12 billion could have saved roads that would cost US$40–45 billion to restore.[2] The response was one of the most widely adopted institutional reforms in African infrastructure: the second-generation road fund.
The reform: commercialising roads
The Road Maintenance Initiative, launched in 1988 by the UN Economic Commission for Africa and the World Bank within the Sub-Saharan Africa Transport Policy Program (SSATP), set out to treat roads more like a utility.[3] Heggie’s framework rested on four building blocks: involving road users in ownership through road boards, securing an adequate and stable flow of funds through a road tariff, clarifying responsibilities, and managing roads on a business-like basis.[1]
An early SSATP review of ten countries identified the essentials: funding from user charges rather than budget transfers, an independent board with road-user representatives, the ability to adjust tariffs, direct payment of levies into the fund, and commercial management with independent audits.[4] These were later developed into a framework for assessing road funds.[5]
The second-generation road fund model
Core design principles distilled by the Road Maintenance Initiative and SSATP
Rapid adoption across the continent
Adoption was fast. By 2005, 24 of 28 countries tracked by SSATP had established road funds,[6] and by 2006 there were 27.[7] In December 2003, road funds founded the African Road Maintenance Funds Association (ARMFA) in Libreville, with 18 signatories.[8] The association now counts 35 member countries.[9][10]
From a pilot initiative to a continental network
Number of road funds in Sub-Saharan Africa and members of the African Road Maintenance Funds Association (ARMFA)
View the data as a table
| Measure | Count |
|---|---|
| Road funds, 2005 | 24 of 28 countries |
| Road funds, 2006 | 27 |
| ARMFA founding signatories, 2003 | 18 |
| ARMFA members, 2015 | 34 |
| ARMFA member countries, 2025 | 35 |
What the funds achieved
Early evaluations were encouraging. Gwilliam and Kumar concluded that second-generation funds had improved funding administration and road condition without undermining fiscal flexibility.[12] SSATP, citing Gwilliam and Kumar, reported experiences ranging from 30% to 80% of maintenance needs met, compared with 15–20% in the early 1990s.[6] The Africa Infrastructure Country Diagnostic found that countries with road funds did significantly better at raising maintenance resources, provided levies were set high enough, and that spending US$1 on maintenance could save about US$4 to the economy.[13] Between 2004 and 2007, half of 16 countries with condition data increased the share of their main network in good or fair condition by more than 10 percentage points.[14]
But dedicated financing proved, as an SSATP review put it, a necessary but not sufficient condition. Only about one-third of funds met routine maintenance needs in 2005.[6] By 2008, only about 20% of road funds studied met all seven SSATP design criteria, and some countries captured as little as half of the levy revenue they anticipated.[15]
A road fund is only as strong as the charge that feeds it and the governance that protects it.
The quiet erosion of the fuel levy
The most persistent weakness has been the level of the user charge itself. In the mid-1990s, SSATP recommended a fuel levy of 8–12 US cents per litre.[4] By 2005 actual levies were typically 4–9 cents against the 10–13 cents considered sufficient,[6] and in 2006 the average was about 8 cents for petrol, against an estimated requirement of 13–15 cents.[7] By 2017 the average was about 9 cents and the median 7.5, while the earlier benchmark, expressed in 2017 dollars, had risen to about 17.4 cents.[16]
Fuel levies have lagged far behind what maintenance requires
Typical fuel levy rates in Sub-Saharan African road funds versus estimated requirements, US cents per litre
View the data as a table
| Year | Observed levy (US c/l) | Requirement (US c/l) |
|---|---|---|
| 1995 | – | 8–12 (recommended) |
| 2005 | 4–9 | 10–13 |
| 2006 | ≈8 (petrol avg) | 13–15 |
| 2017 | avg ≈9; median 7.5 | ≈17.4 (benchmark in 2017 terms) |
The mechanisms are familiar: levies set in local currency, no automatic indexation,[17] and currency depreciation. In Benin, the diesel levy was cut from CFAF 14 to CFAF 4.4 per litre to hold pump prices after the 1994 devaluation.[4] In Ghana, the levy remained at 6 pesewas per litre for years after its introduction in 2005.[18]
The economics of maintenance
The case for protecting maintenance funding rests on well-documented cost multipliers. Rehabilitating a road typically costs three to five times as much as timely preventive maintenance,[2] and South African experience suggests repair costs can rise to six times after three years of neglect and eighteen times after five.[19] Road users also pay: every dollar not spent on maintenance can add two to three dollars in vehicle operating costs.[1]
Deferring maintenance multiplies the bill
Estimated cost multiples from postponing road maintenance
View the data as a table
| Measure | Multiple | Source |
|---|---|---|
| VOC per $1 maintenance saved | $2–3 | Heggie 1995 |
| User waste per $1 not invested | $3 | PIARC |
| Economic saving per $1 spent | ≈$4 | AICD 2010 |
| Rehabilitation vs preventive maintenance | 3–5× | World Bank 1988 |
| After 3 years of neglect (SANRAL) | 6× | TRN-4 |
| After 5 years (SANRAL) | 18× | TRN-4 |
Diversifying the revenue base
Some funds have broadened their revenue beyond fuel. Namibia’s Road Fund Administration combines the fuel levy with vehicle licences, cross-border charges and mass-distance charges on heavy vehicles.[21][22] Zambia has built an extensive tolling network, collecting K2.9 billion in toll revenue in 2023.[23] Tanzania supplements its fuel levy with transit charges of US$6–10 per 100 km depending on axle count.[24]
Namibia shows what a diversified road fund looks like
Road Fund Administration revenue by source, financial year to March 2023, N$ million
View the data as a table
| Revenue source | N$ million |
|---|---|
| Fuel levy | ≈1,000 |
| Vehicle licences | 839.4 |
| Cross-border charges | 163.5 |
| Other local charges | 154 |
| Foreign mass-distance charges | 42.3 |
| Abnormal loads | 14 |
| Road carrier permits | 5 |
Recent developments: pressure from several directions
Recent country experience shows the model under strain. In Ghana, the World Bank reports that maintenance funding met only 37% of needs in 2024, down from 45% in 2018–21, and that only 58% of user-charge revenue was transferred to maintenance budgets in 2016–20.[25] Uganda’s Parliament voted in November 2024 to mainstream the Uganda Road Fund into the Ministry of Works and Transport as part of a wider rationalisation of agencies.[26] Under fiscal reforms introduced in June 2026, Ethiopia’s Ministry of Finance directed that all fuel tax proceeds, part of which had previously been retained by entities including the Road Fund, be remitted to the federal treasury.[27] Tanzania has moved in the other direction: under reforms reported in August 2026, 70% of fuel levy collections now go directly to four sector funds, including the Road Fund.[28]
Recent country experience: diversification, erosion and re-centralisation
Selected road funds, revenue base and recent governance developments
| Country | Revenue base | Recent development |
|---|---|---|
| Tanzania | Fuel levy TSh 263/litre (>97% of income); transit charges US$6–10 per 100 km | Under 2026 reforms, 70% of fuel levy collections are paid directly to four sector funds, including the Road Fund |
| Ghana | Road Fund levy on fuel; levy extended to fuel oil by 2026 legislation | Maintenance funding met 37% of needs in 2024 (45% in 2018–21); only 58% of user charges transferred to maintenance in 2016–20 |
| Namibia | Fuel levy plus licences, cross-border and mass-distance charges | Levy temporarily halved in 2022; increase to N$2.23/litre (from N$1.98) announced in October 2024 |
| Zambia | Fuel levy and an extensive toll network | Toll revenue K2.9bn in 2023, above target, much used to clear contractor arrears |
| Malawi | Fuel levy about 85% of levy collections | Press reports of interrupted levy remittances from the collecting agency |
| Uganda | Road Fund established 2008; had not achieved full second-generation autonomy (2016 assessment) | Parliament passed legislation in November 2024 to mainstream functions into the Ministry of Works |
| Ethiopia | Road Fund Office since 1997, financed mainly by fuel tariffs | 2026 directive (reforms from June 2026) to remit all fuel tax proceeds to the federal treasury |
A note on the evidence
Much of the continent-wide comparative data on road funds dates from 2005–2008 and 2017–2019. We did not find a pan-African dataset more recent than about 2019. Recent country figures come largely from national reports and press coverage, and should be interpreted with that in mind.
The next generation
The World Bank has proposed a “third generation” of road funds able to leverage their revenues for long-term performance-based contracts and public-private partnerships, with a ring-fenced window for restoring roads and a fuel levy of at least 15 US cents per litre, indexed to inflation.[16] In 2021, Ali Ipinge, then ARMFA president and head of Namibia’s Road Fund Administration, warned that road funds were receiving less fuel levy even as vehicle numbers grew, owing to pandemic-reduced fuel demand, and that more fuel-efficient vehicles would further erode the base.[22] Globally, research shows fuel tax revenues are at risk from electrification, especially in lower-income countries.[35] For road funds, the long-term implication is clear: a revenue base built on a single fuel levy will need to evolve.
Lessons from three decades
- Index the chargeAutomatic adjustment for inflation and exchange rates is the single most important protection against real-terms erosion.
- Protect the flow of fundsDirect remittance, transparent transfers and independent audits matter as much as the level of the charge.
- Diversify earlyLicence fees, mass-distance and transit charges and tolls reduce dependence on a single fuel-based revenue stream.
- Link spending to asset managementFunds perform best when allocations follow network condition data and maintenance priorities.
- Maintain the governance bargainUser representation and transparency underpin public acceptance of road user charges.
- Invest in dataComparable, up-to-date data on revenues, spending and road condition are essential for evaluating reform.
Africa’s road funds remain one of the continent’s most important institutional innovations in infrastructure. Their future depends on adapting the original principles of user charging, independence and accountability to a changing vehicle fleet and fiscal environment.
References
- Heggie IG. Management and Financing of Roads: An Agenda for Reform. World Bank Technical Paper 275. Washington, DC: World Bank; 1995. ssatp.org
- World Bank. Road Deterioration in Developing Countries: Causes and Remedies (Policy Study). 1988. worldbank.org
- SSATP. A New Generation of Road Funds to the Rescue of African Roads (Africa Transport Technical Note No. 2). May 1997. ssatp.org
- Balcerac de Richecour A, Heggie IG. African Road Funds: What Works and Why? SSATP Working Paper 14. 1995. ssatp.org
- Brushett S. Framework for Assessment of Road Funds in Africa. World Bank/SSATP; 2000. ssatp.org
- Brushett S. Management and Financing of Road Transport Infrastructure in Africa. SSATP Discussion Paper 4. March 2005. ssatp.org
- Benmaamar M. Financing of Road Maintenance in Sub-Saharan Africa: Reforms and Progress towards Second Generation Road Funds. SSATP Discussion Paper 6. September 2006. ssatp.org
- SSATP. First African Conference of Road Maintenance Funds, Libreville: summary. December 2003. ssatp.org
- The Guardian (Tanzania). Tanzania’s Kalimbaga takes over ARMFA as 22nd General Assembly ends. 22 November 2025. ippmedia.co.tz
- iRAP. iRAP and ARMFA sign MoU for safer African roads. 18 February 2025. irap.org
- tralac. SADC road administrators meet in Namibia’s capital Windhoek. 28 April 2015. tralac.org
- Gwilliam K, Kumar A. How effective are second-generation road funds? A preliminary appraisal. World Bank Research Observer. 2003;18(1):113–128. repec.org
- Foster V, Briceño-Garmendia C (eds). Africa’s Infrastructure: A Time for Transformation. AFD and World Bank; 2010. worldbank.org
- Gwilliam K. Africa’s Transport Infrastructure: Mainstreaming Maintenance and Management. World Bank; 2011. worldbank.org
- Gwilliam K, Foster V, Archondo-Callao R, Briceño-Garmendia C, Nogales A, Sethi K. Roads in Sub-Saharan Africa (AICD Background Paper 14, summary). World Bank; 2008. worldbank.org
- World Bank. Scaling Up Private Sector Participation in Road Asset Management in Sub-Saharan Africa. 2021. worldbank.org
- Addo-Abedi FY, Ellevset O, Benmaamar M. Road funds in Sub-Saharan Africa (PIARC paper). April 2007. piarc.org
- Graphic Online. Ministry wants fuel levy tied to price hikes. 13 August 2013. graphiconline.com
- Burningham S, Stankevich N. Why Road Maintenance Is Important and How to Get It Done. World Bank Transport Note TRN-4. June 2005. worldbank.org
- PIARC and DFID. Save Your Country’s Roads. c.1999. piarc.org
- The Namibian. Road Fund records N$2.3b in revenue. 24 January 2024. namibian.com.na
- Ipinge A. Africa’s road funds under pressure. International Road Federation; 5 August 2021. irf.global
- National Road Fund Agency (Zambia). K2.9 billion collected from toll gates in 2023 (press release). nrfa.org.zm
- Daily News (Tanzania). Ports efficiency boosts Road Fund revenue by 45pc. 5 February 2026. dailynews.co.tz
- MyJoyOnline. Ghana’s road maintenance funding gap deepens as only 37% of needs met – World Bank (reporting the World Bank Ghana Economic Update 2026). 31 August 2026. myjoyonline.com
- Parliament of Uganda. Road agencies scrapped. November 2024. parliament.go.ug
- Capital (Ethiopia). Government mandates full statutory fuel tax collection. 16 August 2026. capitalethiopia.com
- Daily News (Tanzania). Fuel levy reforms boost Road Fund collections. 14 August 2026. dailynews.co.tz
- KPMG. Ghana: Energy sector levies amended for fuel oil imports. 4 September 2026. kpmg.com
- The Namibian. Motorists take a beating from increased road user charges. 2 October 2024. namibian.com.na
- New Era. Road Fund Administration fuel levy and funding gap. 3 November 2023. neweralive.na
- The Nation (Malawi). Roads Fund Administration revenue and fuel levy remittances. c.2024–25. mwnation.com
- ACODE. Uganda Road Fund (Policy Briefing Paper 33). 2016. acode-u.org
- Addis Fortune. Road Fund bags 2.9b Br in revenue. 8 September 2019. addisfortune.news
- Noll B, Schmidt TS, Egli F. Bridging the fuel tax revenue gap in the move to electric mobility (policy brief). Nature Sustainability. 2026. nature.com
Figures are reported as published by each source and may differ in date, definition and currency. Comparative data are dated; see the note in the article. This article draws only on publicly available information.

Leave A Comment